Sunday, June 4, 2017

Matthew help

Historical world help on Matthew passages.

a)Craig Keener is one of best Bible teachers and Three Worlds Teachers,especially on Matthew.
Once you know your text from Matthew, you can click to Craig's video on that section, and fast forward to your exact text.  It's all here.

If your passage is from the first five chapters on Matthew,  click here for a Word doc with some of his written notes that may help.  If your passage is from chapter 5, or chapter 19-28, you have an amazing resource at this click. Craig has written a very helpful commentary in Matthew, and  here  you can see comments on those chapters free.

b)Ray Van Der Laan you'll recogize from class videos as our tour guide to the Holy Land.
His website (here) is full of resources.  Maybe putting "Matthew" or a key word in the search bar will help as you study. Or click "learn" to see articles.

c)There is a good commentary on Matthew free online here.

Thursday, June 1, 2017

faculty notes on teaching/parables

Jesus the Teacher
Prepping  your Three Worlds Presentations should have already surfaced some themes and observations regarding Jesus’ teaching. This section focuses more specifically on why Jesus is an interesting teacher and some of the methods or forms found in his teaching in the Gospels. Brainstorm  why people are so engrossed with Jesus’ teaching, especially their observations from reading the Gospels. What makes him interesting, why do they follow him around and listen?

Four possible reasons (from Robert Stein The Method and Message of Jesus’ Teaching, revised edition. Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1994)
1.    Content. In Jesus’ ministry God is again present among his people and proclaiming his will.
2.   Personality. People loved listening to Jesus teach because of the kind of person he was.
3.    Authority. Jesus teaches with immediate, not derivative, authority.
4.    Forms and techniques. The way in which Jesus taught was exciting and memorable.

Examples of forms and techniques (drawn from your  NOAB   Bible article “Literary Forms in the Gospels” pp. 397-400 NT)

1. Picturesque speech
Includes striking contrasts, vivid metaphors, exaggeration, colorful speech, hyperbole. Examples:
Matt 7.3-5 log and speck, Luke 14.26 hate mother (we hope Jesus is exaggerating in this passage.) Important to realize overstatement is characteristic of the way people talk in Jesus’ culture (sort of like us saying awesome, and eleventy billion). Danger of taking literally something Jesus overstates or of reading as overstatement passages which we don’t like or are hard to do (“sell it all and give it to the poor” or “turn the other cheek”).

2.   Poetry (rhythmical parallelism)
A characteristic of Hebrew poetry (Psalms). Jesus is showing his cultural context here; could be like us using sonnet form, limericks (or nursery rhymes?) (one Greek prof at Fuller teaches his classes the Greek alphabet to the tune of the itsy bitsy spider.) Three kinds:
a. Synonymous = says same thing different way. Luke 6:27-28
            Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you
bless those who bless you, pray for those who abuse you  NOTE: that's a chiasm!
b. Antithetic = second line sets up contrast with first. Matt 7:17-18 Every good tree bears good fruit, but the bad tree bears bad fruit
A good tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a bad tree bear good fruit.
c. Step second line picks up thought/word from first and builds on it, takes it further.
Luke 9:48
Whoever welcomes this child in my name welcomes me,
and whoever welcomes me welcomes the one who sent me
(and whoever welcomes the one who sent me...)

3.   Plays on words (puns)
Another Hebrew Scripture characteristic, double meanings (there’ll be a hot time in the old town tonight). Examples: Matt 16:18petros/petra John 3:8 pneuma (Genesis also, ruach). These are largely lost in translation—read footnotes, a good study Bible will point them out. Jesus is very clever.

4. Proverbs
Remember from Biblical Perspectives?  Yet another Hebrew Scripture genre. Maxims; crisp, forceful, memorable saying. Not only in Scripture—too many cooks spoil the broth, spare the rod spoil the child. Speaking this way is characteristic of wisdom literature, which is a common form of writing in the Middle East. It is an enormous and old tradition in Judaism, although it is not unique to Israel. An entire book of proverbs in Hebrew Scripture; not all of it is “religious”—some good common sense, a place were the commonality of human existence is displayed  Jesus, again reflecting his context, uses proverbs. Example: Matt 6:21 “where your treasure is there your heart will be.”

[Stein adds several other forms, including
 Riddle (saying with hidden meaning) Mark 14:58 “I will destroy this temple that is made with hands and in three days I will build another, not made with hands.”
6.   Irony (contrast between what is stated and what is suggested) Matt 16.2-3 “. . .you know how to interpret the appearance of the sky but you cannot interpret the signs of the times.”
7.   Use of questions Mark 8:27-32 “Who do people say that I am? . .  .But who do you say that I am?”]

8.  Parables (from NOAB article and Stein)
Parables are the most striking feature of Jesus’ teaching. They are what he is most famous for and what he seems to use most frequently. Parables are not unique to Jesus (other teachers of the day and others in Scripture use them, e.g. Nathan to David in 2 Sam 12), but he uses them so effectively and frequently they are characteristic of his teaching. The article explains that 1/3 of Jesus’ spoken words in the Synoptics are parables. The word parable (Greek parabole) refers essentially to a comparison. A look at the way the term is used both in the OT and by Jesus reveals a wide range of meanings, including proverbs, similes, metaphors, similitudes, story parables (most familiar to us perhaps), example parables, and allegories. The thing to remember is that they make a comparison.

Brainstorm why Jesus teaches in parables.
The common answer (to illustrate his teaching) doesn’t go quite deep enough. Arguably, many of the parables don’t make things clearer, but more confusing. (Post a sentence in the forum about how you feel about that). Even the disciples need to have them explained.  Ask someone to read Matt 13:10-13.  There is no getting around the fact that this passage states the parables are not self-evident illustrations. The parables are provocative, often they include a surprising twist; a loud offensive fart in the salon (per Peterson).The parables have a way of disarming hearer, drawing hearer in, and then evoking a response (e.g. Mark 12 parable of vineyard, good Samaritan has this effect too, Luke 10.)

Stein offers these three possible reasons Jesus teaches in parables:

1.       To conceal his teaching from those “outside” (Luke 8:9-10, Mt 13:10-17 & 13:34-35)
2.       To illustrate and reveal his message to his followers
3.       To disarm his listeners—they force a response somehow, leave you wrestling, are provocative.
[Loud farts, as per Peterson]

Example of this disarming: The Good Samaritan.  There was no such thing as a GOOD Samaritan. This is not a nice parable about being nice to people.  People on our day think "Samaritan" is a synonym for nice; as in be a good neighbor!
Jesus intentionally offends by making the dreaded Samaritan the hero of the story,  Jews wouldn't touch a Samaritan; as they were ancient enemies !  They were the worst kind of outcast: They were half-breeds.  In a way, this is worse than an outcast:

Good article in the new Biblical Archaeology by Amy-Jill Levine (emphasis mine):
In the parable, the priest and Levite signal not a concern for ritual purity; rather, in good storytelling fashion, these first two figures anticipate the third: the hero. Jews in the first century (and today) typically are either priests or Levites or Israelites. Thus the expected third figure, the hero, would be an Israelite. The parable shocks us when the third figure is not an Israelite, but a Samaritan.
But numerous interpreters, missing the full import of the shock, describe the Samaritan as the outcast. This approach, while prompting compelling sermons, is the fourth anachronism. Samaritans were not outcasts at the time of Jesus; they were enemies.
In the chapter before the parable (Luke 9:51–56) Luke depicts Samaritans as refusing Jesus hospitality; the apostles James and John suggest retaliation: “Lord, do you want us to command fire to come down from heaven and consume them?” (Luke 9:54). John 4:9 states, “Jews do not share things in common with Samaritans.” The Jewish historian Josephus reports that during the governorship of Cumanus, Samaritans killed “a great many” Galilean pilgrims traveling to Jerusalem (Antiquities 20.118–136). The first-century Jewish person hearing this parable might well think: There is no such thing as a “good Samaritan.” But unless that acknowledgment is made, and help from the Samaritan is accepted, the person in the ditch will die.
The parable offers another vision, a vision of life rather than death. It evokes 2 Chronicles 28, which recounts how the prophet Oded convinced the Samaritans to aid their Judean captives. It insists that enemies can prove to be neighbors, that compassion has no boundaries, and that judging people on the basis of their religion or ethnicity will leave us dying in a ditch.  link

--

Hatred Between Jews and Samaritans


Hatred between Jews and Samaritans was fierce and long-standing. In some ways, it dated all the way back to the days of the patriarchs. Jacob (or Israel) had twelve sons, whose descendants became twelve tribes. Joseph, his favorite, was despised by the other brothers (Gen. 37:3-4), and they attempted to do away with him.
But God intervened and not only preserved Joseph’s life, but used him to preserve the lives of the entire clan. Before his death, Jacob gave Joseph a blessing in which he called him a “fruitful bough by a well” (Gen. 49:22). The blessing was fulfilled, as the territory allotted to the tribes of Joseph’s two sons, Ephraim (“doubly fruitful”) and Manasseh, was the fertile land that eventually became Samaria.
Later, Israel divided into two kingdoms. The northern kingdom, called Israel, established its capital first at Shechem, a revered site in Jewish history, and later at the hilltop city of Samaria.
In 722 B.C. Assyria conquered Israel and took most of its people into captivity. The invaders then brought in Gentile colonists “from Babylon, Cuthah, Ava, Hamath, and from Sepharvaim” (2 Kin. 17:24) to resettle the land. The foreigners brought with them their pagan idols, which the remaining Jews began to worship alongside the God of Israel (2 Kin. 17:29-41). Intermarriages also took place (Ezra 9:1-10:44;Neh. 13:23-28 ).
Meanwhile, the southern kingdom of Judah fell to Babylon in 600 B.C. Its people, too, were carried off into captivity. But 70 years later, a remnant of 43,000 was permitted to return and rebuild Jerusalem. The people who now inhabited the former northern kingdom—the Samaritans—vigorously opposed the repatriation and tried to undermine the attempt to reestablish the nation. Hidden message: this is a test to see if you are reading . Go back to Moodle , and post for answer (a), your answer as to whether you found this hidden message, and have read these notes . LOL, the answer should be YES, but don’t lie . Give another answer if you need to (: For their part, the full-blooded, monotheistic Jews detested the mixed marriages and worship of their northern cousins. So walls of bitterness were erected on both sides and did nothing but harden for the next 550 years.
There are countless modern parallels to the Jewish-Samaritan enmity—indeed, wherever peoples are divided by racial and ethnic barriers. Perhaps that’s why the Gospels and Acts provide so many instances of Samaritans coming into contact with the message of Jesus. It is not the person from the radically different culture on the other side of the world that is hardest to love, but the nearby neighbor whose skin color, language, rituals, values, ancestry, history, and customs are different from one’s own.
Jews had no dealings with the Samaritans. With whom do you have no dealings? Post your personal answer or thoughts on this in Moodle question (b)
The Word in Life Study Bible, New Testament Edition, (Thomas Nelson Publishers, Nashville; 1993), pp. 340-341 

BIB 314: Three Worlds Presentation (online version) expanded intructions

BIB 314: Three Worlds Presentation (online version)
by Faculty Camp/Roberts

SAMPLE 

Assignment:
Prepare a 4-5 minute presentation addressing the three worlds of a single text of your choosing from Matthew’s gospel.

Presentations will be submitted  as a video   Probably easiest to create a video on Youtube or  VidGrid  View the video on Moodle for instructions on how to create and upload a video using Youtube.  Other options or help: see instructions on your introduction video or call FPU Center for Online Learning,

=
(If the three worlds still confuse you, review videos, Week 1 and 2.

It could be that most of your presentation is questions without answers.  That’s OK.

Don’t treat this as a practical “devotional,” it’s a Three Worlds analysis of the text.  You will want to make a practical app in your contemporary world analysis, though.

An abbreviated example of the kinds of information, questions, etc. that could be addressed in each world, in relation to a specific text (Mt 6:1-4) is provided below. Don’t use this example as your presentation! The information below is something accessible by using a study Bible, or a Bible commentary, or a commentary on the book of Matthew.  
CLICK HERE FOR SOME EXCELLENT HELP FOR HISTORICAL INFO ON YOUR SCRIPTURE , 






Here's an ABBREVIATED example Note: another ,example (more  detailed) is found on the bottom of Moodle page under “Extra resources”:
click where it says Week 3: Three World Notes on Prodigal Son in Luke 15.


Abbreviated Example: Three Worlds Presentation Mt 6:1-4

1.       Literary World
In Mt 6:1-4 Jesus talks about giving alms and the right way to go about it. The literary world of this passage would include discussion of what Jesus is saying and how this text unit is put together in relationship to the rest of the Sermon on the Mount (Mt 5-7). What’s his point? Don’t give to be seen giving. Where does this text fit in the bigger picture of the Sermon? Jesus makes a general principle statement in Mt 6:1 about practicing piety, and the alms example is the first of several he gives in chapter 6. This point in the Sermon seems to focus on showing our devotion to God or love of God. In Mt 5 there is also a bigger assertion (verses 17-20) and then a string of examples, but those focus more on showing love to others. These are all important literary world observations related to this text.

2.       Historical World
In terms of the historical world, as a reader trying to make sense of this passage I benefit from knowing what alms and synagogues are, what 1st century Jewish expectations and practices were regarding alms-giving, whether people literally blew a trumpet or whether this is an image Jesus is using to make a point. Does what Jesus say here contrast with common practices or with misguided practices in Judaism in his day? You will need to do actual research to explore elements of the historical world of your text.

3.       Contemporary World
Knowing these things from the literary and historical worlds helps me make a better interpretation of this passage for the present day (contemporary world). What does this text have to teach us today?  (Anyone who has read this by Wed night 11:59, text Dave and tell him you have.  extra cred opp) .Jesus seems to be calling for humility and even anonymity as we give to help others. It’s not supposed to be about how others will think of us as we do this. Jesus seems to understand this act as one way we show we love God (even though other people benefit). And Jesus clearly expects his followers to be giving (he says when not ‘if’ in verse 2).


selective attention fail?

Okay, you watched this video ,
But here's another "selective attention" test on the video:

What did the text/writing on Dave's car stereo say?

Do you remember?  Did you notice?
Click here for the answer...or just watch the video; it's particularly clear  at the very beginning and the very end (inclusio!) of the video.

Now for extra credit, post  in the comments below:

1)Did you catch it, and how did this make you feel? (No shame; most don't).
2)Your thoughts on the very provocative quotes from Kraybill (and Dave) at the link above (or here).

Note: if you don't have one of the listed accounts, just click to post as "anonymous" or guest.. but do be sure to leave your initials so you get the credit

Sunday, May 28, 2017

mighty deeds

Faculty Notes on Jesus’ Mighty Deeds

It is time to consider one aspect of Jesus’ public ministry: the wonders & mighty deeds. This section in chapters 8-9 of Matthew comes immediately after the Sermon on the Mount in chapters 5-7.  Traditionally, these acts have been called “miracles,” which potentially predisposes the reader toward a particular understanding that is not necessarily represented in the gospel.  Mark calls them “deeds of power.”  Luke calls them “deeds of power” and “paradoxes.”  John calls them “signs.”  Matthew calls them “wonders” and “mighty deeds.”  Each gospel differs in the number of stories they tell.  Matthew, Mark and Luke all have around 20, John only 7.  All have some which are unique to their gospel and some which appear in others.  As we learned this morning, each gospel is different.  Even in talking about the same event, the writers will emphasize different things.  By Matthew’s characteristic description of these actions as “wonders” or “mighty deeds,” one question to keep in mind is cui bono? or for whose benefit?  On one level, Jesus is serving and ministering to people.  On another level, throughout the gospel of Matthew, Jesus is constantly locked in a power struggle.  With whom is the conflict in these chapters?


Discussion: LOOK AT PAGE 9 at this link.


1.   What kind of mighty deed?

a.    Healing. Most are healings of physical disability (in all gospels around half of miracles are healings!)  The ailments are permanent and limiting; these are not healings of a common cold.

b.   Exorcisms.

c.    Resuscitations. (Explain not a resurrection, keep same body and will die again.)

d.    Other, misc., ‘nature’


2.   What is the context for the mighty deed?

A quick survey of settings should show there is no predictable place, person, or situation.


3.   How does Jesus perform the mighty deeds? (method)

Jesus’ method is difficult to categorize - sometimes touches, sometimes not, sometimes because asked, sometimes he seeks out, sometimes because of faith, (sometimes faith seems to result, but usually not in Matthew or other Synoptics). Jesus’ method is not formulaic. In thinking of healings and exorcisms today we often seem concerned over having the right formula, saying the right words. But there is no one formula or method that Jesus uses. At points it is hard to categorize or generalize about the mighty deeds, but Jesus has this enigmatic quality in general, so no real surprise.

4.   What is the response? (limit to recorded response in text)

a.    Varied

General reactions of the crowd are amazement, wonder, fear and glorifying God. Response of persons healed is to tell everyone they can find, even when Jesus has told them not to do so. After Jesus turns the water to wine John records “and his disciples believed in him.” What does this mean? Some of the mighty deeds involve demons, and upon their immediate recognition of Jesus as the Holy One of God Jesus silences them. The Pharisees, either when they see or hear about the mighty deeds, are incensed and counsel against him.


b.    Raise questions about who Jesus is (his identity)

What they reveal about his identity is that he has power from God—that is how he explains how he can do what he is doing, and that is why he is such a problem for the religious leaders (doing things only God or the power of God can do). Be careful, mighty deeds do NOT reveal Jesus’ divinity. Other people in the Bible do miracles and they are not divine (Moses, Elijah). And many would say mighty deeds and wonders happen today, but the person who God uses to make them happen is not thought divine, but is simply thought to have God’s power, being used by God.


5.   Why does Jesus perform this mighty deed? (Limit to purpose recorded in text, if any)

Jesus’ motivation is often left unassigned. We draw our own conclusions. Jesus responds to people who come to him and ask for healing, either verbally or by virtue of their being where he is. People are always bringing the sick and possessed to Jesus. It is NOT to draw crowds. Mighty deeds do bring the attention of the public, but this cannot be the primary reason, if it is a reason at all, because Jesus does some in private, silences some recipients, refuses to do them on command. The feeding of the 5000 happens because the crowd has gathered while listening to his teaching, not because he was doing mighty deeds. In general, Jesus does not seem overly concerned with PR. The relationship between faith and mighty deeds is complicated. That Jesus did these solely to generate faith is not an adequate answer when we look at these stories in Matthew—more often faith is a precondition rather than a result (in Synoptics).


6.  What does Matthew emphasize in the stories of Jesus’ “mighty deeds”?    

It is best to try to make sense of purpose in the broader context of each Gospel. Jesus’ mighty deeds are closely connected to the kingdom of heaven and to Jesus’ teaching/proclamation in Matthew. We mostly see Jesus teaching/preaching and doing mighty deeds together. They are presented as a manifestation of the kingdom. The kingdom is present in Jesus’ words and deeds. Faith is usually a precondition (vs. result) for miracles in the Synoptics. The connection between faith and struggle appears frequently in these stories. Faith is demonstrated when one who is seeking a mighty deed encounters a barrier and overcomes it.

                 

Earlier in this course, the case was made that the miracles are connected with the first temptation that addresses whether the definition of wholeness in God’s kingdom is limited to physical well-being. The miracle narratives demonstrate clearly that Jesus responds to physical needs and that these are important. But it is also important to note that these accounts move beyond being limited to physical well-being to a fuller-orbed sense of wholeness (restored hand, can work; leper can be around people). Also, these reflect the limits of the Roman peace, the realities of malnutrition, difficult working settings which may lead to injury, no’ social services’ etc.



Why does Matthew tell us miracle stories about Jesus?


a. Jesus’ miracles are closely connected to Jesus’ teaching/proclamation in Matthew. We see Jesus teaching/preaching and doing miracles together mostly (summary statements that Jesus taught, preached, healed in 4.23-25, 9.35-38).

b. Faith is usually a precondition (vs. result) for miracles in Mt. 

c. Mt’s concern to show Jesus as fulfilling scripture is evident in the way he handles the miracle stories. Jesus’ healing ministry is underscored in Mt’s gospel (4.23; 9.35; 10.1, 7-8;  12.15-16; 14.14; 15.30; 10.2; 21.14-15), as healing is one of the most striking aspects of the prophcied messiah’s ministry.  Mt identifies specific prophecies as fulfilled via miracle in his gospel:  Mt 1:22-23 explains the virgin conception fulfills Is 7.14.  Mt 8.17 explains Jesus’ exorcisms and healings fulfill Is 53.4.  Jesus’ miracles in Mt 11.5 correspond to the miracles described in Is 29.18-19, 35.4-5, 61.1.

d. Miracles show God’s power and God’s kingdom

They show that Jesus is God’s anointed, that he has been anointed with God’s power/Spirit.

Jesus’ miracles are one mode of God's assertion of the power of the kingdom.  The kingdom in fullness still future, but has become reality in J's words and works. 

What is striking about Jesus as a miracle worker is its de-emphasis.  It is debatable that we ever see Jesus perform a mighty deed to demonstrate his power for his own sake.  Miracles are performed for the restoration of the person and to the glory of God, rather than as proof of anything.  Jesus miracles are in fact generally recognized as glorifying God not Jesus, just as Jesus proclaims the Kingdom of God not of himself.  The deeds are signs of the in-breaking of the kingdom, it is true, but they are not the only or "best" sign.  Striking is the restraint of the gospel writers in recording the miracles.  There is little made of them (they simply describe them and go on), and so one must conclude that while these deeds were one aspect of Jesus' ministry they were not its essence or climax.  The miracles are done as a sign of the kingdom of God breaking in, the reality of God's kingly rule present.


Jesus' miracles show God's power and God's kingdom.  How, in relationship to the 4 kinds of miracles we've identified in the gospels? 

i. resurrections show God's power over life and death.             
            ii. healings and exorcisms show God's power as well, and beyond that are unquestionably tied to the coming of the kingdom.  Isaiah talks about coming age of healing when kingdom comes in fullness all will have full healing.  Jesus heals some but not all--genuine manifestation of kingdom, of power of God, but not fullness.  J's mighty works aimed at restoration and release: leper was unclean, unable to mingle. body is healed but person also restored to fellowship with people. (J's table fellowship restores those who are outcast) woman with flow of blood is ritually unclean, cut off from all that is important in Judaism.  Demoniac is unable to relate, uncontainable.  Exorcism restores him to a state of mind which allows him to relate to people, relate to the community.  The kinds of cures in J's healing miracles  are restorative.  They heal conditions which were debilitating, limiting, marginalizing.  People are often made whole in a way that allows them back into the community, so that they are no longer unclean or no longer have to beg but may work and contribute.  The healings and exorcisms reveal the kingdom as an whole, inclusive community.


iii. The last category, of "misc" miracles is where the teaching connection is the most clear I think.  There is symbolic meaning in Jesus' miracles too--they are signs which reveal something about who Jesus is (the one who brings the kingdom) and about the shape of the kingdom itself.  These misc miracles have an "object lesson" quality I think.  Feeding of 5000, J is bread of life.  There is this symbolic thing in the miracles too, the place where the teaching of the kingdom is most visibly a part of what the miracles are accomplishing--Jesus teaching in word and deed, sometimes in these mighty miraculous works.
-by Camp/Roberts

--


kenosis (Greek word for self-emptying):

HOW DID JESUS DO HIS MIRACLES??


In thinking about  living selflessly like Jesus did...

fill in this blank:
The Scripture suggests that Jesus was able to do miracles, and have 

supernatural knowledge, because he was ___________.

Here are some answers students have given:
If you answered "God" ...
and not 'human (trusting in God)"...read on:
--------------------------------------------


INVERSION/KENOSIS
Some theologians call this "Spirit Christology" or "kenosis",  whether or not  this proposed theology is consistently true. If it is, it would almost move this question into the realm of "essential" doctrines, because it then provides the very key to how we are to live in relation to daily Christian life, walking in the power and possibilities of the Spirit; doing the "greater works than Jesus" that Jesus flatly and unapologetically predicted we would do. Now, not every proponent of "Spirit Christology" or "kenosis theology" is biblical or orthodox, so hear me when I say that I know I don't agree with everyone using these categories. The basic argument would be this; to put it bluntly, as one preacher did for shock value:

"Jesus did nothing on earth as God! "

Wow, better unpack that! Now, that statement doesn't have to imply He was not God.. He was, is and always will be fully God in my Book! It's just that He didn't. during His earthly ministry, anyway..do anything out of His innate, inherent and intrinsic Godhood. He voluntarily surrendered the rights to use and access His God hood's attributes... such as omniscience, or power to do mighty miracles. Several
Scriptures come into play: John 5:19 and 30 offer that Jesus did nothing in and of Himself, but only did what the Father and Spirit told/led/empowered Him to do. Philippians 2:6-11 asserts that Jesus didn't take advantage of, or even access of the rights and power of His Godhood, which would be "robbery," and a violation of the whole point of His incarnation; His coming to earth. Instead of functioning out of His eternal power and prerogative as Almighty God, He "emptied Himself". A by-product of this, is as Hebrews affirms "Jesus know every temptation we have endured by His own experience" (2:18 and 4:15). I also love to shock congregations by asking "When Jesus did miracles on earth, how was He able to do those miracles?" Well-trained evangelicals of course automatically answer, "Because He was God!" When actually, that may be the wrong answer all together. Of course He was God, no debate. But the only Scriptural answer to "How did He do those miracles?" is "in the power of the Spirit". And witness Matt. 12:28: He cast out demons; not because He was God and could do so, but as a human "by the power of the Spirit." Thus, that is the "key" key, crucial catch, and ancient but overlooked secret as to how we, mere humans, are to do the same works He did, even greater. (Jesus said that, not me. Blame Him: John 14:12) 



Answer: We do them through "checking in" with the same Father Jesus checked in with while on earth; and trusting,...radically; to the point where the supernatural almost becomes natural and norm... the same Spirit Jesus trusted. (Note Jesus, a few sentences later, suggests that is His secret, and ours. He simply passes the torch to us, but not without the sharing the same equipping Holy Spirit: verses 16-17).Such deep trust and dependency doesn't make us Jesus, of course, but they do position us to trust the timing and voice of the Father, and prompting and power of the Spirit, as radically as Jesus did...with similar and "even greater" results! If JESUS never did anything in and of Himself (John 5:19 and 30), who do we think WE are?

When Jesus asked, in Mark 5:30, "Who touched me?," did He mean it, or was this a test? If "Spirit Christology" is true, one could answer the former, without sacrificing an iota of essential, foundational evangelical theology. When Jesus said even He (Matthew 24:36) did not know the day or hour of His return, was that a lie?. No, and this "lack of knowledge" on the part of a member of the all-knowing Trinity poses no problem. I would propose that He knows now, but He chose not to know on earth. This was all part of His modeling a complete self-emptying. This, though, is core to my third question:" How consistent and complete is this theology.? Did Jesus ever do anything 'on earth as God', even though He was God? And Lord, is this profound truth so profound that to miss it allows us to miss the 'normal' life you have intended for us?"

Whatever the ultimate answer to this question the Lord would give me, the bottom line question I keep hearing in the meantime. and "real time" is haunting: "Have I yet trusted as completely and recklessly as I could in the leading of the Father and the power of the Sprit? I almost don't even care if I do a greater work or not, I just want to be found faithful, and be an answer to Jesus' wild and waiting prophecy of John 14:12. 

I love Dwight Edwards' penetrating, "must-be- wrestled- with" self-questions :

1. What have I done recently that could not be duplicated by an unbeliever, no matter how hard they tried?

2.What blatant evidence of the supernatural God has leaked out of my life?

Questions indeed!


baptation notes

We might  suggest that the same three temptations Jesus faced in Chapter 4 were

 repeated,
              recast and
                            remixed throughout the rest of the gospel, at different points in Jesus' life...

 -------------
-the baptism of Jesus  (chapter 3) and the temptations (chapter 4) should be read together as one literary unit or paragraph 

https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhdlmGwkmuLfFutp1iMpcxlzeZxDV9U5IO-gOIxLT-Q-fKB3LF2EqIsrpEl_RReUGr0zdpdvfUUS7MUOaHik6cf3UYIgHYFxJ3mr0KwVlC92_6e6QGBUH-QwnO6dFuO2uD7oOe4RmN5h54Z/s320/upsidedownupsidedown.jpg
Especially helpful is the suggestion by Donald Kraybill ("The Upside Down Kingdom") and Ray Van Der Laan  that throughout  his earthly life, Jesus was revisited by remixes of the original three temptations ("testations" ) of the devil"in chapter 4.

Kraybill provocatively proffers the following taxonomy of the temptations; suggesting that any later temptation Jesus faced (or we face) is at heart in one of these three spheres:


https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgqNFr9_H660UqoQ6pbwqu33DM9-gpWBz7yqQmFohXUmOmHHDFR02T_ithtd_gGEba6Eq5gt-w0NHSV2vHPQZ-N32zM9lfFzAm9saBveNLYUg1lzSIFKuQKYjoPYz5D9vuWus3yAhxvntA/s200/venn-3.png
1=  Bread into stones: Economic 

2=Jump from temple and test God:Religious 

 3=Own all kingdoms: Political; 


Henri Nouwen ("in the Name of Jesus" )breaks it down this way:


1=  Bread into stones:  temptation to be relevant

 2=Jump from temple and test God:   temptation to be spectacular  

3=Own all kingdoms: Political;   temptation to be rule over

So, it may be useful to plot out various temptations along your life timeline, and ask which of Jesus' temptation are each is  tied to.


SO..if every temptation can be filed under one of the three categories:



Economic    Religious   Political..

or

Relevant    Spectacular   Rule over

..under which does  any temptation (sexual etc) occur?


https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgzV1ij6bMP4q29RnihTMX3a03oZk09wH_bBTh8B2haoqR2mA3Lge8-mk2nhgyFjNnc07yRLP430gOwRGh1WpKdTVHHVd3xVQuLPOUe2eT3u3o9rnPPKivuYdiEk2JV9bAwqzaINWkTtSY/s320/temptjerico.jpg
How might virtually all temptations (the three Jesus faced, or others you could name) be fundamentally economic?  Kraybill, you'll remember, calls the bread temptation "economic," but how might any/all others temptations trace to this root?
HINT: We noted that he term economics comes from the 
Ancient Greekοἰκονομία (oikonomia, "management of a household, administration") from Î¿á¼¶ÎºÎ¿Ï‚ (oikos, "house") + Î½ÏŒÎ¼Î¿Ï‚ (nomos, "custom" or "law"), hence "rules of the house(hold)".[1
 





Note  that the baptism of Jesus  (chapter 3) and the temptations (chapter 4) should be read together as one literary unit or paragraph ( a "coupling" or "particularization") as two items connected.

Remember how important repeated words are..in this case,  "SON":


https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEimwHFzmmp8mjetASI8OG5sZb8TXg40uFbeRDfN53JAsP0nvY0Q4vv6CO9cyZ2E-Zp6dax2L7vttv6qjjLvXuRBSTY_MdRfYKmb3RmdC74j8T1T-4lNS6J2rIpmI4Xj9KExtDGJ9SkspRhg/s400/sonship+001.jpg
GENERALIZATION/PARTICULARIZATION





-The segue is direct..."Then after his baptism, Jesus was led by the Spirit  into the desert for temptation by the devil."  (Matt. 4:1)



-In light of that, ask In what other ways do the baptism and temptation connect?
How does baptism prepare for temptation?



NOTE:






The devil's text ,

"IF 
you are the son of God.."

might better be translated
(according to the Greek word used) as:

"SINCE   
you are the son of God.."

What difference might it make?  Is the devil wondering/questioning asking Jesus if he is son of God?  Or is he assuming it; he and Jesus both know that he is...and thus "Since you are the Son of God, what kind of ways can I tempt you to use/abuse that Sonship?"
--
Van Der lann, in "Jesus Our Desert – The Three Temptations") proposes that the three "temptations" Jesus met in Matthew 4 were the same three  that show up  (repackaged, revisited) throughout Jesus' timeline on earth...right up to, and especially including the cross (as in, not avoiding it) .Several examples:


·                     Jesus put God ahead of family ("Who are my brothers and sisters?"  "Whoever loves father and mother more than me cannot be my disciple."-Matthew 12:46-48...in fact, how many ways can you find in that whole chapter  where Jesus re-encounters versions of one of the testations?
·                     When people reported Herod wanted to kill him, he was not concerned (Luke 13)
·                     When people wanted to make him king by force, he walked away  (John 6:15)
·                     When the crowds were hungry, the disciples  wanted Jesus to feed them.  He refused (Feeding of the Multitude)
·                     The "get behind me, Satan" comment to Peter when Peter suggested Jesus should bypass the cross (Matthew 18)
·                     "go ahead and use Your power; the cross is going to hurt" 

 
 The  Van Der Laan video offered lots of help on how the Testations of Jesus are related to/equated to/hyperlinked to the Testations of Israel in Exodus, Numbers. Deuteronomy.  It is no accident that all three testations of Jesus were found in different form in the OT, as well as the Scriptures Jesus used to counter the testations.

Though it is obvious who "The Son (of God)" is in Matthew (Jesus), unless we know the literary/historical background, we miss that in the Old Testament, that phrase is used for Israel/God's people.   (see  Exodus 4:22-23 and especially the way Matt 2:15 quotes Hosea 11:1)
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEimwHFzmmp8mjetASI8OG5sZb8TXg40uFbeRDfN53JAsP0nvY0Q4vv6CO9cyZ2E-Zp6dax2L7vttv6qjjLvXuRBSTY_MdRfYKmb3RmdC74j8T1T-4lNS6J2rIpmI4Xj9KExtDGJ9SkspRhg/s200/sonship+001.jpg




Now we realize that God tested/the devil tempted the first "SON" in a similar way.
Jesus the Son succeeds (in 40 days) in "reversing the curse" that Israel the Son inherited by not passing it (in 40 years).


Jesus is not only (in a sense) the
New Moses,
 but (in a sense) the New Israel
 (for help on that important point, see this  article,
and this). https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjhyphenhypheniD2O_PJTpue9WdTNEKmP3AUn4n7VaLpZ7MIEoBSd2LibROfoo-PPZjNVs_ZxVDFDS-4WKAviSjkoZtGPwui_w9aTbWXo0PZBrbsTr1ECqE8LNzvQaNfYs-nomXg5f40xWJ_KNwUNwe8/s640/testatoipns40+001.jpg 




VanDer Laan suggested that the heart of Jesus' "success" was consistently  and persistently keeping the "Shema,"   and not caving into a (mis)use of power.  This is the "binder" of the testations: Love God and neighbor.Thus



Q).Who is Jesus in Matthew?
A.) The One who, unlike Israel, passed the wilderness testations by loving God with all his heart, soul, mind and strength....and refusing to give into using "right-handed"  (a la Capon) power.
VanderLaan prefers to translate "tests" instead of "temptations."
You have seen that I have coined the word "testations"  It would seen that in Scripture that God tests, and the devil tempts...and sometimes both are going on simultaneously. 


HERE are some helpful questions you might think about if you want to pursue this topic::



·                     1)What were the three temptations of Jesus in Matthew 4:1-11, Compare any ways Mark's account,  Mark 1:12-13  and  Luke's account, Luke 4:1-13 differ, and suggest any reasons why.
·                     2)How does Nouewen summarize the three temptations(1=to be relevant  2=to be spectacular 3=to rule over). H?  How do you (use your own words)?
·                     3)How do the three temptations connect to the historical and literary world of the Hebrew ("Old')Testament?
·                     4)How do the three temptations connect to the contemporary world of Jesus and the disciples?
·                     5)List and discuss several possible ways that versions of the three temptations reoccur and are revisited  throughout Jesus' life in Matthew's gospel?  (How is Jesus tested/tempted elswhere in Matthew, and how are the temptations versions of a similar one (two, or three) that he faced in the original temptation passage?  (see Kraybill, p. 34)
·                     6)What are the three core temptations you face, and how have they revisited you  throughout your timeline?  How would you categorize them using Nouwen's categories?  Using the three categories of the "Shema"  (heart/mind/might) a la  Vander Laan'?  Using Kraybill's three categories (1=Economic 2=Religious  3=Political; see chapters 1-4 of "Upside Down Kingdom")
·                     7)What have you learned about passing these tests/resiisting these temptations?
·                     8)What does all of this  (the Matt 4 Scripture, and testing/tempting) have to do with the Kingdom?
·                     9)Discuss how the passages that deal with Jesus not being immune to temptation( Hebrews 2:17-18, Hebrews 4:14-16,  and Hebrews 5:7-9) affect your views of  "Who is Jesus?" and of Jesus' divinity and humanity.